Creamy Instant Pot Yogurt with Raw Milk (A Simple Homestead Method)

Jump to Recipe

This post contains affiliate links. This means I earn a small commission at no cost to you. You can view my affiliate disclosure here.

One of the things commonly seen on the homestead is a jar of homemade yogurt tucked into the refrigerator: thick, creamy, and made with care. Yogurt is one of those quiet staples that has nourished families for generations, long before grocery store shelves offered endless options in plastic cups.

Making yogurt at home doesn’t have to be complicated or intimidating. With an Instant Pot, a simple culture, and good-quality raw milk, you can create rich, nourishing yogurt with very little hands-on time. This method is gentle, reliable, and perfectly suited for a slow, traditional kitchen even in the middle of modern life.

Why Make Yogurt in the Instant Pot?

The Instant Pot takes the guesswork out of yogurt-making by holding a steady, warm temperature. This is exactly what yogurt cultures need to thrive. It allows you to step away, tend to other things, and return to a finished batch without hovering over the stove.

For homesteaders and from-scratch cooks, this method is especially appealing because it:

• Uses simple, whole ingredients
• Requires very little active time
• Produces consistent results
• Fits easily into a weekly kitchen rhythm

It’s a beautiful blend of old-world food traditions and modern convenience.

Using Raw Milk for Homemade Yogurt

Raw milk brings a rich flavor and creamy texture to homemade yogurt. Because it hasn’t been ultra-pasteurized, it behaves a little differently than store-bought milk. This is why this recipe gently warms the milk instead of fully heating it.

The goal here isn’t to scald the milk, but simply to warm it enough to dissolve the gelatin and activate the culture without damaging the milk itself.

Note: Always source raw milk from a trusted farm and follow local regulations.

Why Gelatin Is Used in This Recipe

Gelatin helps create a thicker, spoonable yogurt without straining. This is especially helpful when working with raw milk, which can produce a softer set than conventional milk.

A small amount goes a long way, giving you a creamy texture while keeping the process simple and approachable.

Ingredients You’ll Need

This recipe relies on just a few wholesome ingredients:

• Raw milk
• Gelatin
• A high-quality yogurt culture

That’s it. No fillers, no thickeners you can’t pronounce... just real food.

How to Make Instant Pot Yogurt with Raw Milk

This method works whether your Instant Pot has a yogurt button or not. The key is maintaining a gentle, consistent temperature.

If Your Instant Pot Has a Yogurt Setting

Start by pouring your raw milk directly into the Instant Pot. Press the yogurt button, then press adjust when the display indicates it’s going to boil the milk. You’re only aiming to warm the milk slightly not heat it fully.

Once the milk is warm, sprinkle in just over a tablespoon of gelatin and stir well, allowing it to dissolve completely. As soon as the gelatin has dissolved, press cancel. Be careful not to let the milk get too hot.

Stir in your yogurt culture, place the lid on the Instant Pot, and make sure the venting knob is set to venting if you’re using the standard lid.

Press the yogurt button again, press adjust, and set it to the normal setting. Set the timer for 8 hours and allow the yogurt to culture undisturbed.

After 8 hours, let the yogurt cool slightly, then transfer it to the refrigerator to set for 24 hours.

If Your Instant Pot Does NOT Have a Yogurt Setting

Pour the raw milk into your Instant Pot and select the sous vide setting. Set the temperature to 105°F and the timer for 8 hours.

As the milk begins to warm, sprinkle in the gelatin and stir until fully dissolved. Once the Instant Pot reaches 105°F and beeps, stir in your yogurt culture.

Allow the yogurt to culture at 105°F for the full 8 hours. When finished, let it cool before transferring it to the refrigerator to set for 24 hours.

Letting the Yogurt Set

While the yogurt is technically done after the culturing period, it will continue to thicken as it chills. Allowing it to rest in the refrigerator for a full 24 hours gives you the best texture and flavor.

This patience is rewarded with a creamy, gently tangy yogurt that feels deeply nourishing.

How to Enjoy Homemade Yogurt

Homemade yogurt is wonderfully versatile and fits easily into everyday meals.

Try serving it:

• With fresh or dried fruit
• Drizzled with honey or maple syrup
• Alongside soaked oat granola or sourdough granola
• Blended into smoothies
• Used in baking or savory sauces

It’s one of those quiet staples that always seems to find a place at the table.

A Simple Rhythm Worth Keeping

Yogurt-making is more than a recipe; it’s a rhythm. A pot of warm milk, a little patience, and a living culture quietly doing its work while the day goes on around you.

In a fast-paced world, these small, steady traditions matter. And this simple Instant Pot yogurt is a beautiful place to begin.

Sweet & Creamy Raw Milk Recipes:

Raw Milk Sour Cream

Raw Milk Butter

Raw Milk Eggnog

Raw Milk Kefir

If you make this recipe, be sure to leave me a star rating and a comment below. Share what you made and tag me on Instagram@keepingitholistic! For more simple sourdough recipes & guidance, small-space gardening tips, and cozy, slow living inspiration, subscribe to my newsletter and follow me on YouTube and Instagram!

📖 Recipe